Startup Failures

Posted on July 28th, 2008 by Jack

Recently, Roger Ehrenberg published his post mortem on his experiences with Monitor110.

Roger’s top-seven mistakes:

  1. The lack of a single, “the buck stops here” leader until too late in the game
  2. No separation between the technology organization and the product organization
  3. Too much PR, too early
  4. Too much money
  5. Not close enough to the customer
  6. Slow to adapt to market reality
  7. Disagreement on strategy both within the Company and with the Board

There’s many things that can be discussed and learned by looking at the details of this list.  But when I look at it from a very high level, it all points to 2 major issues — A lack of planning and a lack of leadership.

“Battle is a highly fluid situation. You - You plan on your contingencies, and I have. You keep your initiative, and I will. But what you don’t do is share command. It’s never a good idea.” — Vic Deakins (John Travolta), Broken Arrow, 1996

And this, to me, is a symptom of the web 2.0 mentality of creating a business web-site based on a high concept pitch with no plan and no real leadership.  I guess when the VC is only investing a few hundred thousand dollars, it really doesn’t matter.

But real businesses have an idea of who their customers are, what the customer wants, what the customer is willing to pay, and how the business will make money.  And all of this is known before a single penny is spent.

And real leaders lead!

Edit 1: Fixed Typos

Tempest Fugit

Posted on July 14th, 2008 by Jack

Time can be a real pest when it flys by without you noticing it.

Some time soon (I hope) I’ll be back to writing….

Windfall Profits?

Posted on June 14th, 2008 by Jack

There has been a lot of talk recently, particularly by Obama and the democrats in Congress for re-enacting a Windfall Profits tax on the oil industry. But what exactly are windfall profits and how does this apply to the startup entrepreneur?

The Economist defines windfall profit as a controversial concept, often used by politicians to justify imposing a TAX on PROFIT that in theory is earned unexpectedly, through circumstances beyond the control of the company concerned, and is thus deemed undeserved and ripe for the taking by the tax authorities.

Does this definition fit the current situation? Clearly, the tax authorities (Congress and the Democratic Candidate for President) want to take the profit. And clearly the authorities believe that the profit is undeserved. Many of the proponents of the current proposals for windfall taxes on oil have been claiming that Chevron or Exxon are making $1300 a minute in profit, or a billion a day, or many other shocking claims on the absolute value of the profit. And, if you’re not involved in big business on a day to day basis, the numbers are really, really big.

But are the authorities, particularly Obama and the Democrats, correct?

Here’s a basic analysis using the 2008 Fortune 1000 list.

N = 1000 Revenues
($ millions)
Profits
($ millions)
Profit %
Average 11,975.07 724.46 6.0%
Min 1,629.70 -38,732.00 -118.3%
Median 4,619.50 253.30 5.4%
Max 378,799.00 40,610.00 70.9%
Standard Deviation 26,308.06 2,814.67 11.6%
  • Ranked by Revenues, only 2 Oil companies make the top 10. Wal-Mart ranks #1 at $6 billion more than Exxon Mobil. The only tech company AT&T at #10.
  • Ranked by Profit, only 2 Oil Companies make the top 10. Exxon-Mobil ranks #1, but GE takes #2 before Chevron’s #3. In tech, Microsoft ranks 6, and AT&T 9.
  • Ranked by Net Margin, no Oil companies make the top 10. Exxon-Mobil, with 10.9% margin ranks 219. Chevron, with 8.9%, ranks 298. This compares to Microsoft (27.5%) at 25 and Google (25.3%) at 34.

It will take a long time for a startup or entrepreneur to make the F1000. However, high-tech businesses do have high profit %. Looking at the % ranking, we see Mirant, an electricity generator at 70.9%, which may be an outlier, as the next in rank is Blackstone, in the PE business, at 53.2%. Gilead Sciences, at #7, is at 38.2%.

When I created the financial model for my business, I calculated a 39% net profit long-term. Looking at these figures, I don’t find it completely out of the question. Of course it’s aggressively high. But if I don’t shoot for that goal, I’ll never create a real business.

On the other hand, it is pure hubris for Congress to go after the oil business, and to not, at the same time, attack GE, Bank of Ameria, or the Oracle of Omaha.

The Rankings

Top 10 Gross Revenue

Fortune
1000 Rank
Company Revenues
($ millions)
Profits
($ millions)
Profit %
1 Wal-Mart Stores 378,799.00 12,731.00 3.4%
2 Exxon Mobil 372,824.00 40,610.00 10.9%
3 Chevron 210,783.00 18,688.00 8.9%
4 General Motors 182,347.00 -38,732.00 -21.2%
5 ConocoPhillips 178,558.00 11,891.00 6.7%
6 General Electric 176,656.00 22,208.00 12.6%
7 Ford Motor 172,468.00 -2,723.00 -1.6%
8 Citigroup 159,229.00 3,617.00 2.3%
9 Bank of America Corp. 119,190.00 14,982.00 12.6%
10 AT&T 118,928.00 11,951.00 10.0%

Top 10 Net Profit

Fortune
1000 Rank
Company Revenues
($ millions)
Profits
($ millions)
Profit %
2 Exxon Mobil 372,824.00 40,610.00 10.9%
6 General Electric 176,656.00 22,208.00 12.6%
3 Chevron 210,783.00 18,688.00 8.9%
12 J.P. Morgan Chase & Co. 116,353.00 15,365.00 13.2%
9 Bank of America Corp. 119,190.00 14,982.00 12.6%
44 Microsoft 51,122.00 14,065.00 27.5%
11 Berkshire Hathaway 118,245.00 13,213.00 11.2%
1 Wal-Mart Stores 378,799.00 12,731.00 3.4%
10 AT&T 118,928.00 11,951.00 10.0%
5 ConocoPhillips 178,558.00 11,891.00 6.7%

Top 10 Profit %

Fortune
1000 Rank
Company Revenues
($ millions)
Profits
($ millions)
Profit %
708 Mirant 2,815.00 1,995.00 70.9%
666 Blackstone Group 3,050.10 1,623.20 53.2%
855 ENSCO International 2,143.80 992 46.3%
853 Equity Residential 2,147.20 989.6 46.1%
913 MEMC Electronic Materials 1,921.80 826.2 43.0%
402 Charles Schwab 6,063.00 2,407.00 39.7%
536 Gilead Sciences 4,230.00 1,615.30 38.2%
816 DST Systems 2,302.50 874.7 38.0%
959 CME Group 1,756.10 658.5 37.5%
297 Qualcomm 8,871.00 3,303.00 37.2%

Presenting to Win - Jerry Weissman

Posted on June 9th, 2008 by Jack

Jerry Weissman’s Book Presenting To Win is an excellent reference for creating presentations, and killing what Jerry calls MEGO: Mine Eyes Glaze Over.

This book was recommended to me some time ago by Jim Long of Gabriel Ventures during an SVASE Event. I finally got around to reading it, and can see that it will be an excellent reference. I’ll probably have to by the Kindle version as well, so that I have it with me to show others.

The book has three basic sections, although it’s organized into 14 chapters. The first section is an intro, covering both Weissman’s background as well as why you need to create better presentations, and, most importantly, WIIFY. No, that’s not a Nintendo reference; it’s an acronym for What’s In It For You, which is the motivation factor that makes people pay attention to the presentation.

The second section discusses brainstorming and organizing your presentation into a story with one of the 16 possible flows:

  1. Modular
  2. Chronological
  3. Physical
  4. Spatial
  5. Problem/Solution
  6. Issues/Actions
  7. Opportunity/Leveratge
  8. Form/Function
  9. Features/Benefits
  10. case Study
  11. Argument/Fallacy
  12. Compare/Contrast
  13. Matrix
  14. Parallel Tracks
  15. Rhetorical
  16. Numerical

The discussion on the flows and their uses is very helpful. Weissman’s layout of brainstorming and how to turn it into a story is very intriguing but lacking in some details. I wish he expounded more on this, as it is the hardest part of creating a presentation (and probably the hardest to explain in words, so I do give him a little leeway…)

The third section is the technical nuts and bolts. Rather than discussion typography, Weissman refers to the latin phrase de gustibus non est disputandum - there’s no arguing taste. Instead, he gives a small discourse on perception psychology. Because we read from left to right, things coming in from the left are natural and things coming from the right are unnatural.

I can see where this will be one of those books that needs to be revisited from time to time for a refresher course.

Understanding You Different Customers - For a Single Sale

Posted on May 30th, 2008 by Jack

While commenting on the The Future of Storage blog post Does Anyone Care About Efficiency Of Storage?, I starting thinking about all of the different customers involved in a single sale. Since the impetus (and my company) surround storage, we’ll focus on this product and market.

The Setup

Generic product

A NAS (Network Attached Storage) Solution with 10 TB of storage.

Generic Customer

A small enterprise - 1500 employees, a corporate data center, corporate IT staff

The Customer List

IT Staff

The IT staff has specific technical requirements for the product, the management of the product, and the integration of the product into their production environment. Quite often, they have relationships with other storage vendors that have to be broken in order to make the sale.

CIO

The CIO has to ensure that the generic solution (NAS) as well as the specific solution (us as a vendor) meet with all the strategic goals of the company - long term, financial, number/size/type of vendors, etc.

COO

The COO has to ensure business continuity, and has to be convinced that installing and integrating a new storage system will not cause any interruptions to the corporation’s work.

CEO & Board of Directors

Depending on the storage vendor and the type of customer, 10TB NAS solutions can cross the border from discretionary and departmental budget spending to corporate capital asset purchases. In this case, the CEO & BoD have their own set of objectives and objections that have to be met.

End Users

The end users may often have different requirements from IT for storage. For most end users, storage is a commodity on with the same value as pens and paper. As long as it’s there, we can get our job done. If we run out, then the work quickly grinds to a halt and there are a lot of very unhappy end users. Also, like pens and paper, end users perceive storage to be infinitely cheap, and therefore in complete abundance. Rationing of storage is not appreciated nor tolerated very well.

While end users are almost never included in the purchase process, if the end user expectations are not met, negative brand associations may result. For example, if, during the transition of files from the old storage system to the new storage system results in lost or corrupt files, the end users are very quick to blame the new stuff, as the old stuff was perceived to “just work”.

It is important for a new storage player to ensure that they meet with all the customers and determine their expectations for the system. Failure to meet expectations, even with a “successful” engagement, will quickly drive the Customer Lifetime Value to Zero.

August 8 News tramadol delivery, cheap tramadol no rx, Order Now Ultram, online prescription for tramadol, buy tramadol, shipping tramadol, tramadol without a rx, buy tramadol, order discount tramadol, tramadol overnight without prescription, order tramadol next day delivery, tramadol without prescription overnight shipping, Buy cheap tramadol us online, online tramadol cod, order tramadol to uk, tramadol no consultation fees, tramadol sales, cod delivery tramadol, buy cheap tramadol without prescription, buy tramadol order cod, buy discount tramadol online, tramadol next day delivery, order tramadol online pharmacies cash on delivery, us tramadol, buy tramadol pay, cod tramadol no prescription, tramadol 180, tramadol xr buy online cheap, tramadol COD next day, order tramadol online with cod, cheapest tramadol available online, generic tramadol tablets, tramadol pay COD, buy discount tramadol no prescription, cheap tramadol prescriptions, tramadol cod, tramadol prescription from doctors online, tramadol shipped cod, need to buy cheap tramadol and pay by, order tramadol, tramadol without rx, buying tramadol cod, low price tramadol without prescription, tramadol 50 mg tablets, tramadol with cash on delivery, tramadol no prescription, 180 tramadol tablets with, cod tramadol 120, tramadol prescription drug, Free Shipping on Tramadol Orders, order tramadol cod, tramadol shipped, tramadol overnight fedex, tramadol ultracet, tramadol on line no prescription, tramadol no prescription cash on delivery, Tramadol no prior rx needed, cheapest tramadol online, buy tramadol overnight delivery, buy tramadol online without dr approval, tramadol on delivery, cod cheap tramadol, 180 ct tramadol payment with, tramadol in us pharmacy pay by, 180 ct tramadol, tramadol orders cod, how to get prescription of tramadol, tramadol shipped cod, tramadol online next day, next day tramadol, tramadol fedex overnight, 180 ct tramadol payment options, ordering tramadol online, buy tramadol with cod, tramadol shipped with, overnight buy tramadol, only tramadol free consult, tramadol buy in UK, tramadol next day cod fedex, tramadol next day, order tramadol online no prescription, buy tramadol online cod, pharmacies that ship tramadol via, buy tramadol saterday del pay cod, tramadol fedex delivery, tramadol c.o.d overnight delivery, buy tramadol medication cod, online pharmacy fedex C.O.D tramadol, Tramadol and description, Tramadol prescription, Buy tramadol with american express, tramadol overnight cod, buy tramadol for saturday delivery, tramadol next day cash on delivery, online pharmacy tramadol, tramadol fedex, online tramadol with delivery, tramadol ship to 50 states, discount tramadol fast delivery, tramadol with next day delivery without prescription with free shipping, tramadol pharmacy cod saturday delivery, buy cheap tramadol 50 mg, pharmacies tramadol cod, buy tramadol online canadian no script, order tramadol online without prescription, fedex tramadol online cod, Tramadol cheap no rx, buy tramadol cash on delivery, tramadol online no prescription, tramadol no prescription drug, tramadol without a presciption, no prescription cod tramadol, overnight tramadol cod shipping, 180 tramadol cheap with, pharmacies tramadol pay by, tramadol online cheap, by tramadol online for cod, order tramadol hcl with cod, tramadol fedex no prescription, cheap tramadol overnight free, order tramadol online, online doctor consultation for tramadol, tramadol without dr, tramadol no rx, tramadol online no script, buy discount tramadol, tramadol free overnight cod, tramadol cash delivery, tramadol overnight, tramadol pay by, buy tramadol online no script with cod, tramadol ultram, generic tramadol no prescription overnight, tramadol overnight fed ex, tramadol cod accepted, Online Tramadol COD pharmacy, tramadol 377, get discount tramadol now, cod tramadol delivery, buy cheap tramadol overnight, tramadol saturday delivery, buy no prescription tramadol, by money order order tramadol, tramadol hcl 50 mg, tramadol no doctors consult, buy tramadol online by, order tramadol cheap, tramadol cheap, how to get a doctor to prescript tramadol, tramadol prescription consultations +, Buy Tramadol 50mg, buy tramadol without a prescription overnight delivery, tramadol without a prescription, overnight tramadol cod, discount tramadol, tramadol no prescription required, buy cheap tramadol no Prescription, tramadol 100 mg overnight, order tramadol online by fedex, cheap tramadol no prescription nextday shipping, Order Now Ultram 50mg, cheapest tramadol, cheap tramadol, cheap tramadol overnight delivery, online pharmacies tramadol, cheap tramadol fedex overnight, cheap tramadol no prescription, tramadol medication online, tramadol fedex shipping, tramadol pay, tramadol cod online, 180 tramadol delivered on saturday, order tramadol, buy tramadol with saturday delivery, buy tramadol no rx, tramadol in mexico without prescription, buy discount tramadol now, tramadol shipping, buy tramadol online, tramadol fast delivery, tramadol medicine pay, buy cod guestbook.html inurl tramadol, overnight tramadol, tramadol med pay cod, tramadol over night, 100 mg tramadol, drug use tramadol, tramadol saturday, tramadol online purchase, discount tramadol online no rx, tramadol hcl, pharmacys buy tramadol pay, real tramadol in us pharmacy, cheap tramadol, buy tramadol cheap, tramadol overnight, tramadol with saturday delivery, TRAMADOL ONLINE FEDEX COD FREE CONSULT, tramadol online cash on delivery, tramadol cod shipping, Tramadol on sale, tramadol rx, cheap tramadol online, cheap tramadol c.o.d., buy tramadol cheap medication, ship tramadol to arkansas payment, cheap tramadol no prescription next day delivery, tramadol shipped COD on saturday delivery, tramadol overnight online, tramadol fed ex, order tramadol cod saturday, buying tramadol without a script, Tramadol free overnight shipping, tramadol without presciption, Cash on deliver Tramadol overnight, buy payment tramadol, ordering tramadol online no membership overnight delivery, pharmacies pay by cod tramadol, no prescription tramadol fedex delivery, tramadol overnight COD, Best Prices on Tramadol, tramadol pay COD, tramadol cod next day, tramadol online no prescription overnight, buy tramadol, Tramadol oral, Tramadol cheap no rx free from india, tramadol hydrochloride, purchase discount tramadol, tramadol drug, tramadol free fedex shipping, us tramadol fedex, buy cheapest tramadol online, cheap tramadol cod, buy tramadol online no prescription, tramadol cheap, by cod tramadol, pharmacies for tramadol pay, buy cheap tramadol online inurl, buy discount tramadol free shipping, online tramadol, pharmacies tramadol pay, tramadol free consultation, pharmacies for tramadol pay w phone, tramadol cheap next day, Tramadol shipped to florida, tramadol online, online pharmacy fedex cod tramadol, tramadol online fed ex, tramadol cash on delivery, tramadol in us pharmacy, Tramadol hcl 50mg, pharmacy tramadol no prescrption, tramadol cod saturday delivery, tramadol perscription on line, buying tramadol online without prescription, tramadol with, tramadol overnight no script mastercard accepted, Tramadol great buy, tramadol 50mg, tramadol cor 127 in us pharmacy, tramadol payment, buy cheap tramadol online with cod, low price tramadol, tramadol payment, tramadol next day delivery, free shipping tramadol, tramadol overnight shipping, buy tramadol online overseas, Tramadol orders C.O.D., buy cheap tramadol, how to get tramadol without, buy tramadol online consultation us, 180 tramadol with cod, medication tramadol hcl, buy tramadol no prescription, lowest price of tramadol, where to buy tramadol, buy cheap tramadol online, tramadol without prescription, discount tramadol online, buy tramadol overnight cod, Tramadol no prescription pharmacy discounter, no prescription next day delivery tramadol, tramadol 180 pay cod, cheap tramadol cash on delivery, us tramadol cod sales, Tramadol medication, 180 tramadol cod, no prescription tramadol, tramadols overnighted cod, Cheap tramadol NO RX, Buy tramadol index, buy tramadol tablets without prescription, tramadol cod delivery next day, order tramadol by, tramadol 120, pharmachies for tramadol pay cod, tramadol for sale cod, by delivery saturday tramadol, tramadol online with no prescription or membership, tramadol free overnight fedex delivery, buy tramadol overnight cod, cheap tramadol without prescription, cheap tramadol free fedex, tramadol next day cash on delivery, buy tramadol free consultation, buy tramadol overnight via electronic check or, no prescription cod tramadol, canada tramadol no prescription, buy tramadol overnight, cod tramadol, tramadol india, TRAMADOL ONLINE FEDEX COD FREE CONSULT, lowest cost tramadol pharmacy, tramadol no prescription, buy cheapest tramadol, buy tramadol cod, tramadol online si, discount tramadol without prescription, tramadol overnight no prescription, tramadol online without prescription, tramadol withdraw, pharmacy tramadol, tramadol cheap no rx required canada, tramadol shipped on saturday, tramadol without a prescription and cod delivery, Tramadol 180 cod, tramadol online no perscription, buy tramadol cheap cod no rx, no prescription tramadol and cod, purchase tramadol shipping, very cheap tramadol, cheap tramadol next day delivery, fedex tramadol, cheap tramadol, tramadol with free fedex overnight, buy tramadol shipped ups, no prescription required for tramadol, cheap tramadol without prescription overnight delivery, tramadol with free dr consultation, purchase tramadol cod, buy tramadol at a cheap price online, online tramadol, tramadol pay by cod, tramadol, buying tramadol in us pharmacy, buying tramadol without a prescription, order tramadol cod next day delivery, Tramadol Overnight COD no prescription, buy tramadol online cash on delivery, 180 ct tramadol with, buy tramadol and pay by cod, order prescription free tramadol, tramadol ups, tramadol overnight delivery cheap, tramadol no prescription overnight cod delivery, tramadol cod overnight delivery, cod delivery tramadol, cheap tramadol over night